Dwarves in Philippines plan to build colony where they can live in peace

Alejandro Doron

Alejandro Doron, one of Manila’s many dwarves, hopes to escape daily harassment and ridicule by starting a dwarf-only community on a plot of land in Manila

Alejandro Doron Jr, left, hopes that the Philippines government will help with his plans to create a colony that would also become a tourist attraction. Photograph: Kate Hodal

With his jet-black hair, golden skin and hazel eyes, Alejandro Doron Jr is the sort of man who regularly stops people in their tracks. He may be good-looking, but he knows why people stare. He’s small – 117cm (3ft 10in) small, in fact.

As one of Manila’s many unanos or dwarves, Doron hopes to end the harassment he faces daily by starting the Philippines‘ very first little people colony.

The 35-year-old bartender works at Manila’s only "dwarf bar", the Hobbit House, where he and his colleagues, ranging in height from 76cm to 135cm, serve tourists Hefeweizen beer and New York ribeye steaks, as dwarf comedians and Elvis impersonators perform on stage.

Just a 10-minute drive away, in the red light district of Makati, other dwarves don gold-and-black Speedos to perform in oil wrestling matches. Still others undress for fascinated sex tourists.

While there are no official figures for the Philippines, dwarfism – of which there are more than 200 distinct varieties – is generally defined as being 147cm or shorter.

The most common condition, achondroplasia, is thought to affect around one in 25,000 people.

Manila’s community of little people are highly visible because many of them have come to the capital to find both work and each other, says Doron.

"Otherwise, they are like me: the only dwarf in their village," vulnerable to both physical and verbal abuse.

Critics have questioned whether dwarf-specific jobs such as Doron’s are exploitative, but for many little people in the Philippines, such work can be a godsend.

While Filipinos are, on average, of short stature (163cm for men and 152cm for women), a minimum height requirement of 157cm exists for many jobs.

"I’m a computer programmer by profession, but even if you have a good resumé and meet the job qualifications, [potential employers] say there’s a height restriction, so they can’t hire you," says Jonathan Cancela, 30, who, at 142cm, has worked for the past few years as an oil wrestler at the Ringside bar.

The Philippines has had a longstanding fascination with little people, popularised in the 1970s by TV shows and films on dwarf boxing, wrestling, comedy and kung fu.

Even today, if a little person is the only dwarf in the immediate family, which occurs in about 80% of cases worldwide, popular Filipino legend dictates that the mother must have been watching "dwarf TV" while she was pregnant.

Such an interest in little people means that many of them, at least in Manila, have plenty of work. Doron often dons fancy dress to play leprechauns and monsters for TV shows, children’s parties and even so-called Snow White weddings. He also recently starred as a cross-dressing, papal-robed shaman in the film Son of God.

At the three-storey squat he shares with 11 others – including his own family and that of his sister’s – Doron slowly sips a glass of cola while his partner Olivia Fernandez, 38, who is 157cm, rocks their one-year-old baby in her arms. Of their five children, two are dwarves. Fifteen-year-old Rina has taken the day off from school for fear of bullying.

"Some boys wanted to cause a rumble, so I am home," she says quietly, standing at 86cm.

"It is hard for me – people say I’m small, they shout at me. But I just go to school to learn more about life."

Fernandez says she has faced opposition from both friends and family over her relationship with Doron; and seven-year-old daughter Glysdi, also a dwarf, gets so much verbal abuse that "she is always crying".

"I told them, if people talk about you, don’t listen to what they say," says Doron, who left secondary school early due to harassment.

"But it’s hard. It’s the natural attitude of the people … I prayed that all my kids would be normal, but I have no choice – this is what God gave me."

Being free from this constant abuse, says Doron, is the reason why he and about 30 other dwarves are planning to establish a colony.

An investor has donated 16,000 sq m of land near Manila, though the fields still have to be cleared, the houses built, and the businesses started.

But money is tight, and Doron hopes that local politicians will help with funding and that the colony will one day become a tourist hotspot.

So-called dwarf towns have existed in the past – in Coney Island at the turn of the century and more recently in Kunming, China – but not everyone agrees that they help in the long run.

"The answer is not segregation," says Gary Arnold of the charity Little People of America.

"The answer is raising awareness about differences and doing all we can to promote communities that embrace and are inclusive of all differences."

Dressed in children’s jeans and a T-shirt, Doron slowly winds his way back to work through alleys crowded with caged roosters and stray dogs.

A neighbour, wiping away the afternoon’s heat with a handkerchief, cackles loudly as he passes. "Ooooh!" she laughs. "There goes the dwarf!"

Doron turns and smiles at her, then continues deliberately on his way.

The Guardian

ENABLE AND EMPOWER

The draft Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill breaks new ground in protecting the civil and political rights of the disabled, says Hemchhaya De

Enable

Syed Sallauddin Pasha feels that India needs an Anna Hazare to fight for disability rights. The art therapist-cum-classical dance trainer would know what an uphill task it is for persons with disabilities to make their mark. He has trained about 150 dancers with disabilities in his Delhi-based organisation, Ability Unlimited Foundation, known for its exquisite “Bharatanatyam on wheels” performed by dancers on wheelchairs.

“I have written several times to leading government organisations like Sangeet Natak Akademy to help differently-abled artistes in India participate in premier art festivals across the country,” says Pasha. “But unfortunately, unlike government-backed initiatives in the West, artistes with disabilities in this country are given short shrift.”

Pasha hopes the government will pass stronger laws to end such social inequalities. And he feels the recently drafted Rights of Persons with Disabilities (RPD) Bill, 2010, might just be the answer to his prayers.

In April last year, the ministry of social justice and empowerment appointed a committee to prepare a draft RPD Bill that seeks to replace the existing Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act of 1995. After a year of exhaustive state and national-level discussions with various stakeholders, the committee — comprising disability rights activists, government representatives, legal scholars and medical professionals — has submitted the final draft of the bill to the ministry.

“We have received the final draft from the committee we appointed. We’ll now follow the usual legislative process, such as inviting suggestions from state governments and sending them to a parliamentary standing committee, before it’s tabled in Parliament,” says a senior official at the ministry who does not wish to be named.

“This is a standard practice with all bills,” says Sudha Kaul, head of the Indian Institute of Cerebral Palsy, Calcutta, under whose chairpersonship the committee drafted the bill. “The proposed law seeks to put in place a charter of rights in accordance with the mandate of the United Nations Convention on Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD) to which India is a signatory.”

The UNCRPD — which was adopted on December 13, 2006, at the United Nations Headquarters in New York — speaks of a “paradigm shift” in attitudes towards persons with disabilities. It says that the disabled should be seen not as objects of charity but as “subjects” who are free to exercise their rights like any other individual in society. The legislation proposed is inspired by these UNCRPD principles.

In addition to the 1995 Act, India has other disability-specific laws like the National Trust Act, which is concerned with the welfare of people with autism, cerebral palsy and multiple disabilities, and the Rehabilitation Council of India Act that regulates the training of rehabilitation professionals in the disability sector. Nevertheless, experts say these laws are narrow in scope. They stress that the need of the hour is a more comprehensive, rights-based law for persons with disabilities who constitute about two per cent of the Indian population.

Says Amita Dhanda, professor and head, Centre for Disability Studies, Nalsar University of Law, Hyderabad, who was part of the team which drafted the RPD Bill, “Yes, we have laws, but they are welfare-oriented. We do not have a rights-based law in the country and consequently the present legislation is required.” She adds that the existing disability law makes room for some of the socio-economic rights recognised by the UNCRPD such as education and employment. “But the law is totally silent on the issue of equality and non-discrimination. It does not look at the practical implementation of civil-political rights,” she says.

The draft RPD Bill, on the other hand, seems to be breaking substantial new grounds. Take the provision for service animals — the first time that such a provision has been included in a law for disabled people. Section 82 of the draft bill says, “The appropriate governments and establishments shall permit and facilitate the use of service animals by persons with disabilities on roads, buildings, all transport systems, public facility or service.” Furthermore, a person with disability will have the right “to be accompanied by a service animal without being required to pay an extra charge”.

The proposed law is also geared to the protection of the rights of women and children with disabilities. Experts say that women with disabilities are often forced to opt for sterilisation. Section 30 of the draft bill addresses this problem. It states, “Persons with disabilities, particularly women and children with disabilities, shall have the right to retain their fertility” and “no person with disability shall be subject to any medical procedure which leads to or could lead to infertility without their free and informed consent”.

Any violation of this will attract imprisonment and a fine. As Section 153 specifies, “whoever performs, conducts or directs any medical procedure to be performed on a woman with disability which leads to or is likely to lead to termination of pregnancy without her express consent” could face 10 years in jail along with a fine. And any caregiver, a parent or a guardian, who fails to prevent such wrongful medical procedure is also liable to be imprisoned and fined. Moreover, there is a provision for disabled persons to opt for postal ballot if they cannot vote in person, and for electoral booths to be made completely accessible to them. The bill also proposes 7 per cent reservation in higher education for the disabled, raising it from the current one per cent.

Most social activists who work with disabled persons are happy with the draft bill. Says Bhargavi Davar, director, Centre for Advocacy in Mental Health, Pune, “It is a very comprehensive legislation, and has covered vast new areas. We hope the sheer scope of the new legislation will lead to the immediate formation of a ministry for disability affairs, which the sector has been asking for, for a long time.”

However, one particular provision in the draft bill has come in for considerable criticism. This relates to “limited guardianship” or a joint decision-making process between a person with disability and his or her guardian. “The limitations on legal capacity compromises all the rights or freedoms promised in the draft,” insists Davar.

The drafting panel contends that the proposed bill, like the UNCRPD, recognises that all persons with disabilities can exercise legal capacity on an equal basis with others in all areas of life. “However, there is a duty on the part of appropriate governments to provide support. The choice to accept or refuse that support is with persons with disabilities,” says Dhanda. She adds that a number of persons with disabilities are in plenary guardianship today. A plenary guardian is one who takes decisions in the best interest of the person with disabilities but without consulting him or her. “The bill has replaced this system with limited guardianship,” says Dhanda. “Insofar as limited guardianship is required to operate on mutual understanding and trust, it is in consonance with the rights-based orientation of the law.”

On the whole, there is little doubt that the RPD Bill will usher a new era in disability rights in the country. For the differently abled, it may be the beginning of a better life.

The Telegraph

Centre Invites Proposals from States for Giving Central Assistance to the tune of Rs. 100 Crore to Provide Barrier free Environment in Govt Buildings and to Make Government Websites Accessible to Persons With Disabilities

The Centre has invited proposals from States to give central assistance to provide barrier free environment in important State Government buildings in the State Secretariat, Collectorates, Main Hospitals, Universities and other important Government offices to ensure that these are accessible to the Persons with Disabilities (PwDs).  Central assistance will also be given to make Government Websites at the State and District levels accessible to PwDs as per guidelines for Indian Government Websites issued by the Department of Administrative Reforms & Public Grievances.Proposals from States have been invited by the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment under the “Scheme for Implementation of PwD Act, 1995 (SIPDA)” after effecting a major increase in the annual allocation under this Scheme from Rs. 15-20 crore in the past to Rs. 100 crore this year.

The Ministry has made a notional allocation to the States based upon their population of PwDs as per Census, 2001 and has requested them to sent proposals on that basis. For example, a notional allocation of Rs. 16.50 crore has been made for Uttar Pradesh, 8.90 crore for West Bengal, 7.90 crore for Tamil Nadu, 7.60 crore for Maharashtra, 6.70 crore for Madhya Pradesh and 6.60 crore for Andhra Pradesh. Similar notional allocations have also been communicated to other States based on their population of PwDs.

It may be recalled that the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD), 2008, to which India is a signatory, calls for making buildings, work places, facilities including information, communication and other services etc accessible to PwDs on an equal basis. The Union Minister of Social Justice & Empowerment, Shri Mukul Wasnik, had written to the Chief Ministers of all States earlier this year urging them to make the important buildings and websites of the State Government accessible to People with disabilities in a time bound manner.

Central assistance on significant scale is provided to states under “Scheme for Implementation of PwD Act, 1995 (SIPDA) to encourage them to move in that direction.

VBA

How families and coteries are ruining disabled sports in India

The disability sports sector in India seems to be in gross disarray with the administration of the sector in the stranglehold of a coterie of people who seem to have no interest in either the disabled or in sports. National disabled sporting federations seem to be run like mom-and-pop outfits with hardly any national character.Yet, not only does the sports ministry seem blind to such obvious  mismanagement, it  seems to be actively funding and perpetuating these outfits shelling out public money in crores every year to these organisations in the name of promoting sports for the disabled.

The rot seems to start right from the apex body of disability sports, the Paralympic Committee of India (PCI). The PCI is headed by the president Ratan Singh whose son Amar Singh is the vice-president.  Amar Singh’s son, Raghavendra Singh is an escort or so-called professional masseuse for disabled sports teams. He is too young with no professional qualification to be a sports masseur. Yet, he gets selected, despite qualified persons in sports medicine with  professional training in sports massage being  available, says a disabled sportsperson on conditions of anonymity. Sportspersons are scared of speaking out against the office bearers who have a vice-like grip over their sporting  careers, a threat they seem to use to good  effect in keeping them from protesting.

When contacted, Ratan Singh admitted to the problem of office bearers signing up as escorts and managers.  “Office bearers accompany teams as they can sort out any problem easily. I can do little about this. But as you can see, my son and I are not signed up for any team. My grandson is there for being a qualified masseuse. I did not make the selection,” said Singh.

Every single office bearer of PCI has listed himself as manager or escort with various teams accompanying them to countries   like the US, Germany, Malaysia, Taiwan, Australia, Spain and so on. KR Shankar Iyer, the treasurer of PCI, is listed as an escort for the athletics and volleyball teams and manager for the wheelchair fencing team. CV Raghunath,
administrator of PCI, is listed as an escort for athletics, volleyball and the powerlifting teams. M Mahadev, the secretary of the PCI, is listed to accompany the athletics and volleyball teams.

The office bearers of national federations for each sport do what is done in PCI, which is to list themselves as escorts and managers or appoint themselves as the coach and take their wives along as escorts. Quite understandably, these so-called coaches, managers and escorts are of little help to the disabled sportspeople when they go abroad as they are allegedly too busy on jaunts and sightseeing with their wives and  friends who accompany them as team escorts.  Each so-called national federation is single-city based, filled with people from the same city and no national representation. For instance, powerlifting is run from Nagpur, swimming from Gwalior and athletics from Bangalore. The PCI, the overarching national body for all disability sports is controlled by a bunch of people in Bangalore.

The selection of sportspersons from all over the country for different sports is decided by small coteries of people of one city and allegations of irregularities in selection are common. It is the sportspersons who suffer the consequences of such mismanagement. Last month, the athletics team that was supposed to be in Germany for an international meet could not go as those responsible did not apply for the visa in time.

Most teams don’t even have basic sports equipment such as the swimming team not have approved swimming costumes or the table tennis team does not have wheelchairs.

Despite these malpractices being pretty obvious in the team lists for each sport submitted by PCI to the ministry as Long Term Development Plan 2010, the sports ministry seems oblivious to it and the allocation to these federations has been rising steadily every year going from about Rs 10 lakh in 2005 to over Rs 5 crore in 2010.

(Source: Long  Term Development Plan 2010 submitted by PCI to sports  ministry)

List of office bearers of various sports

ATHLETICS

  • Raghavendra Singh, escort: Grandson of PCI president, Ratan Singh and son of Amar Singh, PCI vice-president
  • M Mahadev, team manager: Secretary of PCI
  • David Premnath, coach: General secretary of Wheelchair Basketball Federation of India
  • CV Raghunath, escort: Administrator of PCI
  • Diana Joyline D’Souza, escort: Was personal secretary to PCI president
  • KR Shankar, escort: Treasurer of PCI

SWIMMING

  • VK Dabas, coach: Secretary of Paralympic Swimming Federation of India, also runs Paralympic Committee of Madhya Pradesh
  • Saroj Dabas, escort: Wife of VK Dabas
  • Suresh Kalra, escort: President of PSFI
  • Lalit Gupta, escort: Vice-president of PSFI

VOLLEYBALL

  • H Chandrashekar, cpach: Secretary of Volleyball Federation
  • M Mahadev, escort: Secretary of PCI
  • Chandrashekar, escort: Joint secretary of PCI

WHEELCHAIR FENCING

KR Shankar Iyer, manager: Treasurer of PCI

POWERLIFTING

  • Vijay B Munishwar, coach: President of Paralympic Powerlifting Federation and also runs Maharashtra State Paralympic Association
  • Deepali Munishwar, escort: Wife of Munishwar
  • CV Raghunath, escort: Administrator of PCI

TABLE TENNIS

  • R Murali, coach: Secretary of Paralympic TT Federation
  • Gopal Babu, escort: Member of executive committee, PTTFI
  • Shashikala Babu, escort: Wife of Gopal Babu
  • Satyanarayana, manager: President of PTTFI

Rejig of discrimination laws should enshrine equality for all

DOMINIQUE ALLEN
May 3, 2010

The government needs to back its words on human rights with action.

THE Rudd government recently said it would review the four federal anti-discrimination laws with a view to merging  them into a single act.  The review could be the most significant aspect of the government’s new  human rights  framework – but only if the outcome is a law that will effectively tackle inequality. Australian law has prohibited discrimination for more than 30 years. These laws have eradicated the most overt forms of discrimination. Women can’t be prevented from applying for jobs based on gender. People can’t be removed from a pub because of their race. We cannot afford to be complacent; by no means do we live in an equal society.  Women’s participation in the workforce is 58.7 per cent, compared with 72.1 per cent for men, most women work part-time and many industries remain highly segregated. Race discrimination persists. We only have to think of the recent attacks on Indian students in Melbourne or the fact that indigenous people experience a standard of living well below that of the non-indigenous population. A recent ANU study found that a job applicant with a non-Anglo-Saxon sounding name will find it much more difficult to  get a job interview than an applicant with one. People with a disability face many obstacles in accessing buildings,  services and public transport.

The reason for this discrimination is dealt with case by case. There is no institution, like the ACCC or the Ombudsman, that can make sure that people are given a ”fair go” at work or school, or in the services they receive. It is up to victims to do something about discrimination.  If I am discriminated against by a potential employer because I am female and likely to have children soon, my only option, apart from trying to sort the matter out with the employer, is to lodge a complaint with the Australian Human Rights Commission. The commission will arrange a conciliation conference for the parties and we’ll try to resolve the issue. The chances are we will. We’ll spend a few hours discussing what happened and I’ll walk away with a small financial settlement in return for not going to court and keeping the matter confidential. That will resolve the issue for me, but what if there are other women in the workplace who have had a similar experience? What about other employers who are considering doing the same thing? Will my complaint deter them?

The answer is that the system can do little to help people in a similar situation to mine, or to discourage potential discriminators. If the Rudd government simply decides to combine the race, sex, disability and age discrimination acts under one umbrella act, nothing will change; Australia will continue to tackle discrimination in a piecemeal fashion. There is another option. The government could commit to actively tackling inequality and introduce the legal tools to achieve it. This is not a novel idea. Other countries have been doing it for decades. In the US, at least since the Kennedy administration, government contractors have been required to take action to ensure their workforces are  representative, or they risk being ineligible for government contracts. In Northern Ireland, specific employers have been required to achieve fair participation of the Catholic and Protestant communities in the workforce since 1989. South Africa introduced similar requirements to remedy decades of apartheid. In Britain, equality is promoted beyond employment. Public authorities have to consider the need to promote equality of opportunity based on race, gender and disability when carrying out their functions. This meant that when the Department of Health became aware that diabetes was prevalent among Britain’s Afro-Caribbean community, it made sure that its national framework for  tackling diabetes took the needs of that community into consideration. The Rudd government could also follow Victoria’s lead. Just last month, the Victorian government introduced laws that will enable the Equal Opportunity and Human Rights Commission to launch investigations into persistent or entrenched discrimination, rather than relying solely on victims to do something about it. Following an investigation, the commission will work with the organisation to resolve the issue.

The organisation may only need to change its behaviour or it may agree to something more comprehensive, such as developing an action plan to eliminate discrimination. Australian governments were once leaders in promoting equality and protecting human rights on the international stage. Let’s not forget that South Australian women were the first women worldwide to be extended the franchise as well as being allowed to stand for election. The Rudd  government recently reasserted Australia’s commitment to protecting human rights by becoming one of the first countries to sign the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. It’s time for this government to bring that commitment to equality home by introducing laws that actively promote equality and give substance to the catch cry, a ”fair go” for all.

Dr Dominique Allen is a research fellow at the Institute of Legal Studies, Australian Catholic University.

Manmohan promises disabled-friendly laws

FIGHTING FOR THEIR RIGHTS: Physically challenged persons, under the banner of the National Platform for the Rights of the Disabled and led by CPI(M) leader Brinda Karat, march on Parliament Street in New Delhi on Tuesday to press their demands. Photo: V. Sudhersan

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh on Tuesday said the government was in favour of amending the laws, if need be, to make them more disabled-friendly. He gave this assurance to a delegation of the differently-abled persons who met him in Parliament. The delegation was led by CPI (M) MP Brinda Karat.  “The Prime Minister was extremely sympathetic towards the demands of the disabled persons and said their demands were genuine,” Ms. Karat said. Dr. Singh assured the delegation of changing the laws to make them disabled-friendly, if necessary. The Prime Minister interacted with the members of the delegations and enquired about their problems. Talking to The Hindu, Ms. Karat said this was the first time that a delegation of differently-abled persons had visited Parliament House. “It was pointed out to the Parliament staff that there was only one gate (Gate no 9) in Parliament House for the physically disabled people and this was far away from the main entrance,” Ms. Karat said. The delegation also met the Union Minister for Social Justice and Empowerment Mukul Wasnik who told them that the government was finalising a new law for the disabled that would replace the existing law.

Earlier, a large number of people with different forms of disabilities marched to Parliament House to demand a better deal. Marching under the banner, ‘National Platform for the Rights of Disabled Persons,’ the people highlighted the plight of the economically and socially disadvantaged among the disabled, the poor, and the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes. “The basic issue is that of the approach of the government and we must request you to consider our demands not as an act of charity but as fulfilment of entitlements and rights as equal citizens of India. India is a signatory to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the persons with Disabilities which enjoins the government to ensure minimum rights and livelihood to disabled citizens,” the marchers said in a memorandum submitted to the Prime Minister. The demands include a comprehensive social security system for all persons with disabilities and their families including the Antyodaya cards, free health care for disabled persons, amendments to the Right to Education Act to make provision for disabled teachers and professional and identification of jobs for the disabled immediately with annual special recruitment drives each year.

Besides setting up a separate Ministry for disability affairs, the memorandum also sought issuance of a universally valid identity card and replacing the current Persons with Disabilities Act (1995) in consonance with the provisions of the U.N. Convention and harmonising other laws, the disabled persons also wanted proper enumeration of the persons with disabilities. The organisations that participated in the march included the Paschimbanga Rajya Pratibandhi Samaiilani, the Differently Abled Persons Welfare Federation of Thiruvananthapuram, the Karnataka Rajya Angavikalara Mattu Palakara Okkota, the Jharkhand Vikalanga Morcha, the Tamil Nadu Association for the Rights of all types of Disabled and Caregivers and the Vibhinna Prathiba Vanthula Jakkula Vedika of Andhra Pradesh.

The Hindu

Ramasamy will enjoy his drive again

Mohamed Imranullah S.

Denied approval for his modified vehicles, physically challenged lawyer moved court

— Photo: G. Moorthy

disabled driverR.Ramasamy in his modified car.

MADURAI: R. Ramasamy (42), an MBA graduate and practising lawyer, who was paralysed below his waist about 17 years ago, will drive again, thanks to the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court.  Despite his condition, Mr. Ramasamy wanted to drive. He approached an automobile mechanic to modify his car as well as a two-wheeler. He wanted the clutch, brake and accelerator to be operated with hands. The mechanic obliged — he mounted the acceleration control on the gear shaft and placed the brake control, using a lever, below it. The clutch could be activated by pushing down the lever attached to the gear rod.  His two-wheeler did not have to undergo much alteration, but for attaching two extra wheels.  Even as the lawyer was looking forward to drive, Regional Transport Officials here refused to register the vehicles without the approval of the Automotive Research Association of India, Pune.  The ARAI informed him that approval could be given only to company manufactured vehicles.

The lawyer filed a writ petition before the Madras High Court Bench here. Accepting his arguments, Justice Prafulla Kumar Misra held that
government officials could not refuse to register vehicles altered by local mechanics to suit the needs of physically challenged or to issue driving licence for such vehicles.  “A manufacturer of a particular type of vehicle may not think of manufacturing ‘invalid carriage’ (vehicle for physically challenged) on account of economic factors such as lack of demand… Even assuming that invalid carriages were still being manufactured, I do not find any restriction in altering a normal vehicle and re-registering it,” he said.  The officials were directed to consider the lawyer’s applications for registration as well as driving licence afresh in the light of the observations made in the order and to take an appropriate decision within four weeks.

© Copyright 2000 – 2009 The Hindu

Sidewalks become battlegrounds

Disability-rights advocate Scott Crawford of Jackson, rides down Terry Road in Jackson, Miss. on Friday in his motorized wheelchair.

Disability-rights advocate Scott Crawford of Jackson, rides down Terry Road in Jackson,
Miss. on Friday in his motorized wheelchair.

By Chris Joyner, USA TODAY

JACKSON, Miss. — The nation’s crumbling sidewalks have disabled residents taking their wheelchairs to the streets, a potentially dangerous practice that has cash-strapped cities and disability-rights advocates at odds over how to fix the problem.ities across the nation are dealing with eroding sidewalks that do not meet standards set by the Americans with Disabilities Act. Under the ADA, state and local governments cannot discriminate against the disabled in providing “services, programs or activities,” including access to sidewalks.Although there are no specific statistics on the number of accidents involving wheelchairs in streets, according to the U.S. Department of Transportation’s Fatality Analysis Reporting System, disability was a factor in 617 pedestrian traffic fatalities last year.

Disabled residents here take their lives in their hands getting from point A to point B, says Scott Crawford, a disability-rights advocate. In March, James Smith, 68, was killed when an SUV, struck by another vehicle, plowed into his motorized wheelchair on Medgar Evers Boulevard, one of Jackson’s main thoroughfares. Where they exist, the sidewalks often are in such disrepair as to be impassible to people in wheelchairs, says Crawford, leaving the roadway as the only other option. “I’ve been beeped at and honked at and cussed at,” by motorists, he says.

Lois Thibault, coordinator of research for the U.S. Access Board, a federal agency that provides guidance to local governments on ADA issues, said Jackson is in the same boat with a lot of cities that for years stalled spending federal dollars on sidewalks to spend money on roads. “It’s deferred maintenance,” she said. “We’ve been so focused on new construction that we’ve let the maintenance go.” Crawford is a plaintiff in a federal lawsuit aimed at getting the city to comply with ADA standards by making sidewalks, bus stops and other public areas accessible to the disabled. The Justice Department has joined in the lawsuit. In the past 10 years, the Justice Department has inked settlement agreements of ADA complaints with dozens of cities as part of a push called Project Civic Access, an effort to ensure cities eliminate physical and communication barriers for people with disabilities.

Elsewhere:

  • In California, state officials are fighting a federal class-action lawsuit filed by disability-rights advocates who want thousands of wheelchair ramps installed along 2,500 miles of sidewalks on state roads across the state. Mary-Lee Kimber, staff attorney at Disability Rights Advocates, a non-profit law firm representing the plaintiffs, said the two sides are working toward a settlement after a judge last month halted the trial to allow more negotiations. If the state loses, it faces potentially billions of dollars in sidewalk-repair costs.
  • In Arlington, Texas, the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in June that two disabled residents could proceed with a lawsuit against the city over the condition of its sidewalks. John Nevins, attorney for residents Richard Frame and Wendell Decker, said his clients, who are disabled, sued because they could not access the sidewalks in their wheelchairs, keeping them from getting to medical and city services.
  • In Columbia, Mo., the City Council last week passed an ordinance making it a misdemeanor for motorists to harass disabled people in the public rights of way. Mayor Darwin Hindman said the language for wheelchairs and walkers was added to an existing law for bicyclists to protect “more vulnerable classes” of pedestrians.

“As with most cities, we have a certain number of deteriorated sidewalks that are not suitable for wheelchairs,” Hindman said.

Jackson Councilman Kenneth Stokes said the ultimate solution is for the city to fix the sidewalks. In the meantime, Stokes sponsored a measure that passed this month requiring wheelchairs to have reflectors or a blinking light if disabled residents intend to use them in the street after dark.

Joyner reports for TheClarion-Ledger in Jackson, Miss.

USA Today

Tourism e-accessibility and e-inclusion

Thursday, September 03, 2009

Toursm

In their effort to find niche markets, the tourist destinations have finally realised that disabled people constitute an advanced market with advanced needs and lot of perspectives; a market that belongs among the most loyal groups of clients. Let’s not forget that Europe is getting older and the obligations of the countries members of the European Union (http://ec.europa.eu/information_society/activities/einclusion/index_en.htm) increase, therefore more and more opportunities are given to the disabled individuals to travel under the same circumstances as the rest of the citizens.

The journey starts from their house, from their personal computer, usually by searching Google. However, as Abbott (2001) argues, even though internet provides opportunities of democratization of society through freedom of expression, sometimes of even radical opinions, it is still predominated by websites which usually reverberate the dominant ideology and stereotypes, or it is rich in advertising websites which rarely consider disabled individuals as a remarkable market. Therefore, the trip of a person with disabilities is mandatorily continued only on those websites of suppliers or tourist services which can cover their first need of accessibility, by following the various protocols of accessibility for the web design and content, like the ones developed by the World Wide Web Consortium, known as W3C.

Most of the Cypriot and Greek websites of the big tourist enterprises do not meet those criteria and therefore are not accessible, also evidenced by the research of Zafiris and Zacharias (2001 and 2003). The high importance given on the artistic design and not on the usability and accessibility of a website, lefts disabled individuals out of the online marketing. To avoid any possible misunderstandings, at this point we need mention that most of the criteria defined by W3C are easy to achieve, since clear guidelines are given. Those criteria do not necessarily deprive the artistic design of a site. On the contrary, they strengthen good design and facilitate the designer to avoid any possible excesses and mistakes which without realizing may affect the success of the website. The various accessibility protocols include special design guidelines of the web material with regards to accessibility for particular disabilities (e.g visual disability, motor disabilities, etc.) but at the same time include general instructions as to the usability of the website, its readability, the content presentation, the search engines, the easy and well understood reservation systems, like www.sybelio.com, and many more, which contribute in the creation of a human oriented website, which is easily accessible to every citizen of the modern society. Research findings have shown that the accessible design of a website can increase at least 10% the number of the people visiting the website.

If the tourist enterprises of Greece and Cyprus want to attract, and please allow us to repeat here the word want, an inclusive market which doesn’t exclude disability, they should not only build ramps next to the staircases, or create rooms with special equipment, and doors suitable for wheelchairs etc., but they should also give the possibilityof accessibility next to their well designed websites, so that online material, advertising and information will be appropriate and accessible to people with for visual, hearing, motor and learning disabilities, etc. Everybody has the right and we have the obligation to offer exactly the same and equal services we offer to the rest of the community.  The website accessibility should belong in the same legal framework as the physical accessibility. If one organisation offers internet services to the public, the legislation should have enforced it to offer the same services in accessible websites, as has already started in a number of European and other countries with the guidelines of Universal Design.

If Greece and Cyprus become leading markets through accessible internet and offer their tourist services in accessible websites, and this is well advertised, then we “endanger” to become accessible destinations. After all, the conviction of the European Union is that by 2010 all the public websites to become accessible then why not all the tourist websites, too? Of course it is not enough our websites to be accessible. We are obliged to have our towns, villages, beaches and mountain resorts accessible and inclusive, and this is only achieved though real and feasible human oriented plans and strong political decisions by the local authorities, decisions that can be materialized quickly.  My recent experience, in teaching an e-commerce course to 10 young people with hearing disabilities, under the Synergia Programme of the European Union, has confirmed the many opportunities those people have in online marketing.

Petros Mavros is a Business Development Director of Avantless ltd

Travel and Daily News

All hotels to become differently abled friendly

New Delhi, Aug 5 (PTI) In line with international best practices, government has now made it mandatory for all hotels to become differently abled friendly.  Existing and new hotels of all categories all over the country would now have to comply with the requirements for the differently abled persons in respect of accessibility, special rooms with bathrooms and facilities in the public area by September 1, 2010, according to the revised guidelines.

Tourism Ministry has tried to address major concerns to make the classification norms friendlier for differently abled persons by adopting the international best practices, an official release said.  In order to keep abreast with the contemporary requirements of the hospitality industry, Ministry has recently reviewed the norms for approval of hotel projects and guidelines for classification of hotels.

PTI NEWS

Students design railway model for the disabled

Independence Express by KEM students wows judges at AIOTA

Deepa Rao, Parel

A blue train called Independence Express halts at a station called Swavalambanpur. Raju, a physically disabled person, makes a hassle-free entry into the train. Visually impaired and hearing impaired people travel easily in the red City Metro.

This was the idealistic dream of six young minds from KEM’s Occupational Therapy Hospital whose cardboard and clay rendition won them the first prize at the 43rd Annual National Conference of All India Occupational Therapist association (AIOTA). The six-member team including Megha Kamani, Gauri Chavan, Viraj Kasbekar, Asmita Sarang, Samira Dhamapurkar and Manisha Karande spent about three weeks researching the topic, ‘Disabled-friendly Railways’. They visited various railways stations, internet sites, talked to disabled patients and also took inputs from RB Dixit, DCM of CST railway station. “For the 15 days when we worked on the model, we left the college at around 11 pm, and also took back homework,” smiles Megha. What is striking in this model made of corrugated cardboard, craft paper, walkman headphones, aluminium nets and clay is the attention to detail and feasibility. The model has innovative features that focus not just on wheel-chair-bound individuals but also on the visually, auditory and the cognitively impaired. The highlights of the design encompass guiding pathways, Braille maps and signs for the blind, induction loop for the hearing impaired, lifts for energy conservation, portable ramps for accessing trains and non-skid flooring. Dr Ashwini Vaishamapayan who guided the students feels, “Unlike others, our group took both local and long-distance trains into consideration.” Little wonder that the judges were impressed. Says Gauri, “In fact, one of the judges complimented us saying our model inspires the disabled to travel independently.” KEM Hospital, on its part, is making sure that these ideas don’t become history. Professor Dr Anjali Doshi is planning to speak to RB Dixit to see if these suggestions can be incorporated in new trains and stations. “Some of the ideas are cost-effective and need very minor modifications in the existing infrastructure.” Meanwhile, RB Dixit said, “They had come to me with their suggestions. We are already trying to incorporate some in future trains.”

DNA, Bombay 26/01/2006